Ask an AI tool for “the best fractional CMO firms for mid-market B2B” and look at where the answer comes from. A lot of the time it leans on directories and review sites: G2, Clutch, a trade association list, a software marketplace. Other people wrote those pages, so a model treats them as outside evidence.
That makes your profiles on those sites some of the most useful and most neglected assets you own. If a directory describes you badly, an AI tool may repeat it. Nobody chose that for you, but you can fix it.
Why review sites carry weight in AI answers
AI tools try to check claims against sources they do not control. A review site hands them an independent description of what you do, who you serve and how clients rate you. G2 has published its own analyses of how reviews relate to AI citations. Read them with the caveat that they come from a platform with an interest in the answer. The safe conclusion is modest: a complete, current, well-reviewed profile gives an AI tool more to work with.
Pick the platforms your buyers actually use
Not every directory deserves your time. For software, that usually means G2 and similar marketplaces. For services firms it often means Clutch and industry lists, plus any association or partner directories your buyers trust. Run your own buyer questions through AI tools, see which sites show up, and start with those. My Perplexity playbook shows how to run that test.
Get each profile into shape
- Claim it. Unclaimed profiles often hold stale information.
- Describe what you do in plain words, the ones your buyers use.
- Choose the right categories. The wrong one puts you in front of the wrong comparisons.
- Fill every field: services, industries, company size, location.
- Add proof, such as verifiable case studies, awards and links to your best pages.
- Keep the facts the same as on your own site, and review the profile every quarter.
Consistency matters because AI tools compare what different sources say about you. If your site says one thing and your listings say another, the model has to guess which is true, and it may guess wrong.
Ask for reviews in a way that works
Reviews rarely turn up by themselves. Build the request into your process, shortly after a clear win, and make it specific. Ask clients to mention the problem, the work and the result, because that detail is what other buyers and AI tools find useful. Our guide to case studies and testimonials goes further. Here is a request you can adapt.
Subject: A two-minute favor, if you have it
Hi [First name],
Thank you for working with us on [project or service]. It was good to see [specific result or milestone] come together.
If you are happy with how it went, would you share your experience on [platform]? A few sentences is plenty. It helps other buyers who are comparing firms, and it tells us what to keep doing.
It would help most if you could mention:
- what problem you were trying to solve
- what the work involved
- what changed as a result
Here is the direct link: [review link]
If anything fell short, please tell me directly and I will make it right.
Thanks again,
[Name]Never offer payment or gifts for a positive review, and check each platform’s rules on incentives before you offer anything. Platforms differ, and breaking the rules can get a profile removed.
Reply to every review
Thank people for positive reviews and say something specific. Answer negative ones calmly, with facts and an offer to put things right. Replies are public, and prospects read them as a sign of how you behave when something goes wrong.
How to tell whether it is working
Run the same buyer questions every month. Note whether your profiles are cited and whether AI answers describe you accurately. Watch referral traffic from the platforms too. If a competitor is cited and you are not, compare their profile with yours, using our guides on competitor AI visibility and fixing low AI visibility. If you want help, let’s talk.
Sources
- G2 Learn, Do More G2 Reviews Mean More AI Visibility? Insights from 30k Citations (October 2025; published by G2, analysis uses Profound data)
- G2 Learn, Does G2 Get Ranked in AI LLM Search? (G2’s own tracking figures)
- G2 Documentation, Understanding gift card eligibility (checked October 2026)
Frequently asked questions
Do review sites like G2 and Clutch affect AI search results?
They can. AI tools often rely on directories and review sites as independent evidence about what a company does and how clients rate it. Complete, consistent, well-reviewed profiles give them better material, though no one can guarantee a citation.
Which review sites should a B2B company prioritize?
Choose by category. Software companies usually prioritize G2 and similar marketplaces, and services firms often prioritize Clutch and industry or association directories. Run your own buyer questions through AI tools and focus on the sites that show up in the answers.
How do I ask clients for reviews?
Ask shortly after a clear win, by a named person, with a direct link and a simple request. Suggest they mention the problem, the work and the result. Give them an easy route to raise concerns privately, and never offer payment for a positive review.
Should I respond to every review?
Yes. Thank people for positive reviews with something specific, and answer negative ones calmly, with facts and an offer to put things right. Replies are public, and prospects read them as evidence of how you treat clients.
Why does consistency across profiles matter?
AI tools compare what different sources say about you. If your name, services and positioning differ between your website and your listings, the model may be unsure which version is correct and may repeat the weaker one.
How often should I update my directory profiles?
Review each profile every quarter and update it whenever your services, positioning or key facts change. Keep the wording consistent with your website, and add new case studies and proof points as you earn them.
Do AI tools quote review site profiles?
They often draw on public pages that describe a company, and review platforms are among them. A complete, accurate profile gives them better material.
What should a review profile include?
A clear description of who you serve and what you do, accurate service categories, current contact details and fresh reviews that describe real outcomes.
Put this to work
Find out how your budget compares, or talk it through with Brad for 30 minutes.

About 10Louder
10Louder is a brand and marketing strategy firm led by Brad McCormick, Instructor of Digital Marketing Strategy and Performance Management, Southern Methodist University, with twenty-six years of brand strategy in New York, Austin and Dallas.